You are currently viewing Understanding Contract Remedies

Understanding Contract Remedies

When a contract is breached, the repercussions can be significant. Businesses and individuals alike must understand the legal remedies available to mitigate the consequences of a breach. From monetary damages to specific performance, the law provides a spectrum of remedies to ensure fairness, enforce agreements, or make the injured party whole again as a premises liability lawyer can share.

The Spectrum Of Contract Remedies 

According to the Restatement (Second) of Contracts, several remedies can address breaches, including:

Monetary damages. This is often the most straightforward remedy, involving the payment of a sum of money for losses due to the breach. 

Specific performance. This remedy compels the breaching party to perform their contractual duties when monetary damages are insufficient. 

Restitution. This remedy helps ensure one party is not unjustly enriched at the expense of another party by requiring restoration of a specific thing. 

Declaratory judgment. Declaratory judgments help to clarify the rights and obligations of the parties under the contract.

Injunctive relief. This remedy prevents a party from acting in a way that would breach the contract.

Enforcement of Arbitration awards. When a contract dispute has been resolved through arbitration, enforcing the arbitrator’s decision is another available remedy to ensure the injured party is provided relief. 

Expectation Vs. Reliance Damages

When it comes to damages, courts primarily consider two types: expectation and reliance damages. Expectation damages aim to put the injured party in the position they would have been in if the contract had been fulfilled. On the other hand, reliance damages reimburse the injured party for expenses that resulted from relying on the contract. It is often a point of debate in the legal community as to which form of damages is more applicable. However, expectation damages are typically preferred because they consider the potential benefits one would have received from a fulfilled contract, whereas reliance damages are focused on the costs incurred by the injured party. 

The Efficiency Breach Concept

An interesting concept in contract law is the “efficiency breach.” This concept suggests that it might be economically sensible for a party to breach a contract if the cost of breaching is less than the cost of performing, as long as they compensate the injured party. However, this concept is controversial as it can undermine trust in contractual relationships. 

Liquidated Damages And Specific Performance

Liquidated damages are another critical area in contract remedies, involving a predetermined amount agreed upon during the contract formation as compensation for a breach. This is often used in scenarios where actual damages might be difficult to determine.

Specific performance, on the other hand, may be demanded when the subject of the contract is unique or when monetary damages are inadequate. This remedy is often applied in contracts involving the sale of real property or rare goods. 

The Role Of Mitigation And Foreseeability

The law also requires the injured party to mitigate their losses. This means taking reasonable steps to reduce the damage or loss resulting from the breach. Additionally, for damages to be recoverable, they must be foreseeable at the time the contract was made, meaning the breaching party could anticipate potential losses from a breach. 

Emotional Distress And Punitive Damages

Generally, recovery for emotional distress is not available in contract law unless the breach also caused bodily harm or the nature of the contract was such that emotional disturbance was a likely outcome. Punitive damages are also rarely applicable unless the breach involves actions that could independently qualify as a tort. 

In conclusion, contract law is intricate, with a wide range of remedies designed to address various breach scenarios. Understanding these legal concepts is crucial for drafting contracts to protect one’s interests and for navigating disputes efficiently. Legal advice should be sought to tailor contract clauses to specific needs and to understand the implications of various types of breaches and available remedies. 

Thanks to Eglet Adams Eglet Ham and Henriod for their insight on remedies for breach of contract.

If you need help on a case, contact a lawyer near you.